Missing the Sign's

Welcome to Jacksonville, our Skyway is here to serve you. We hope you enjoy your journey and are able to find your station, since we don't know where it is. None of our signs are in "Plainview".

For as long as their have been railroads, (Okay, Skyways, monorails, interurbans etc...) there have been large signs that decorate the ENDS of the platforms or station buildings. Everyone rolling into a station, need only glance out the window and knows where they are at. I am amazed that somehow the guys who did the Skyway station designs, didn't know this little fact?

So where are the signs? Why don't we have nice signs on the ends of all of the stations loudly but tastefully announcing the place of arrival? You see, "Plainview" should be more then just a City in Texas, with great station signs, those signs should be ours as well.

WHAT WE DO RIGHT!

Jacksonville has been it's own favorite whipping boy since I can remember. We have made some really stupid decisions in this City, chasing away Mr. Disney with the line, "We don't do business with carnival people," has to rank right up there with Chevy trying to sell Nova's in Latin America. (No - va = It won't move in Spanish) There have been others, local crooks skimming huge profits off of Flagler when he went to build Hotels in St. Augustine and Jacksonville (Pablo) Beach and caused him to buy out the railroad and build tracks from our City as fast as he could go. Not that the FEC RR is bad, it's just that all of that tourism and industry that fled South with it, once belonged to us. There was a second theme park in Busch Gardens that was stonewalled, and we tossed both the airline and banking industry to Miami, Orlando and Charlotte respectively. So what, if anything in transportation have we done right in Jacksonville? Glad you asked.

JTA, for all of my misgivings about it's "Mass Transit expertise" has done a banner job in highway development in the City. We led the State and indeed the nation (including California) back in the day. We still rank near the top in lane or freeway miles per resident. While I'm not a big fan of sprawl, the relief that has come from projects such as I-295 East (currently 9-A) or JTB has been a Godsend to many residents of the Beaches and Intercoastal Community. Wonderwood Connector to Mayport on the grade of the old Jacksonville, Mayport and Pabl0 Beach Railroad is brilliant. Frankly, the new outer beltway, a possible I-110 or I-210 will also grow to someday serve as a major reliever to downtown congestion. Arlington Expressway, I-95 South in San Marco, The Matthews Bridge, and the Hart Bridge approaches are all due for major redesign and reconstruction. Will it be painless? No. Will it solve everything? No. Then what is the value of it? In terms of congestion relief, Priceless...

JTA'S bus system. Another star in our crown, we rank with the "big boys" of American bus transit. In the October 2007 issue of Metro Magazine's annual 100 largest bus operations in North America, Jacksonville is number 66, behind 17Th ranked Miami-Dade Transit, and 53Rd ranked Broward County Transit, but in front of 71St ranked Lynx (Orlando), 82Nd ranked Pinellas Suncoast Transit and far ahead of 89Th ranked Hillsborough Area Rapid Transit (Tampa). In 1980 we did a internal review of the bus route structure in Jacksonville and found that most had not changed significantly since the last streetcar ran in 1936. Ed Muller, Then Director of JTA held several brain storming sessions before clearing the table of all of the old routes and rebuilding the system on a modern hub and spokes with several cross-current outer connector services.

Starting off about 1900, our bus system took charge when the streetcars were sold out, as one of the first major systems to fall in the now infamous National City Lines conspiracy case. But from this controversial start, we have continued to build and better our network. Today we have a true urban bus network. In fact, many of our buses are "beyond urban" and reach far out into the country or surrounding cities. Beginning with "Twin-Coach" and "Mack" buses all the way to today's new Gilligs, we have always had some of newest, best and brightest bus equipment in the South. Our bus system led the State of Florida in the design and implementation of Express buses and Quality Bus Commuter operations. We were at the top of the game when we introduced large new articulated twin unit coaches for our heavy commuter runs. In fact these same coaches went on a tour of Transit Agency's Statewide in order for them to learn from Jacksonville's leadership. The park and ride lots that sprouted in places like Mandarin, and in freeway cloverleaf's showed both forward thinking and great land use planning. They were originally implemented without disturbing the surrounding neighborhoods. All bus riders will fondly remember the giant new AMC coaches we purchased in the 1970's, nicknamed "Rattlers" because of a tendency for the window frames to produce a constant metallic chatter, they demonstrated to our city a new age of wide, comfortable transit buses. We also jumped on the new Grummans and the GM "new look" coaches as they came on line. Each with their own oddity's, Macks that took a body builder to steer, or Grummans with broken "A" frames. We have lived to improve, and in that light, JTA and Jacksonville has excelled.

We complain constantly about the lack of bus shelters, yet we have many of the newest types scattered throughout the City. We cough on the litter and lack of maintenance at bus stops, however we are a grand and old city with many blighted neighborhoods, and still our bus stops exceed the care given the same in Miami or Browards top ranked agency's. We go on about ugly or smelly buses, but I can truthfully say, I have NEVER been on a filthy Jacksonville bus. I cannot say the same about most other cities of the World I have visited. One memorable trip I made in the Western Hemisphere, included the "deluxe" bus. It had a spare transmission rolling and banging from side to side laying in the floor between the seats. The "deluxe" included a "VOMIT STOP" something some of our US systems might consider, but is just not needed here.

Combine good to excellent freeways and roads, one of the largest bus fleets in the America's and top notch equipment, and you have a recipe for the future. In this area of Mass Transit, Jacksonville doesn't follow the leader, we lead the pack.

Beautiful Northbank of Jacksonville

A City ready to grab at first-rate Mass Transit

Busway to Bust?

Pittsburgh, PA. Where BRT ridership has

become worse each year, are we next?

Jacksonville's Busway to Bust

Would YOU Buy It?

Jacksonville...For whatever reason, a fixed guideway transit system, be it rail, monorail, people mover, trolley bus, or busway, always does better in passenger loads then a flexible type system. Sadly, buses ARE flexible transit in motion and the downside is, they are inferior in attracting a crowd. The Bus Rapid Transit Planners, tell us, "BRT could carry as many passengers as rail," or "BRT uses unique branded vehicles", or "BRT can be as fast as rail", or even their trademark slogan, "BRT is just like rail only cheaper".

Does BRT carry as many passengers as rail? Worldwide, the numbers tell a different story, BRT is not even close. In the few markets where it has excelled, Bogota and Curitiba, Brazil, both Cities are now planning a rail based Metro to replace the BRT trunk lines. This means the taxpayers will have to ante up for two transit systems, when they had a need for only one!

Branded Vehicles? Does this make a difference? Ask yourself if a blue bus will get you home any better then a red bus? How about a bus that is wrapped with advertising? Sorry to say, no matter what you do to the basic vehicle, paint, brand names, hide the wheels behind skirts trying to fool people into thinking they are rail vehicles. WHATEVER! It is still a bus.

BRT could drive as fast as rail? National averages place BRT dead in the middle between regular City Bus Transit and Light Rail Transit in speeds. While it is true the bus COULD go much faster, 50 or 60 miles per hour, the real world conditions of narrow busways or freeway HOV lanes, preclude it from achieving anything but short bursts of speed. Rail on the other hand can and does travel as fast as 79-90 miles per hour in many markets. If they manage to get a BRT bus up to those speeds, I don't want to be on it.

Is BRT really just like rail but cheaper? I'll give this statement the most honest answer I can by picking it apart. As we have seen in speed, usage, or guideway attractiveness it is NOT like rail. Likewise, in spite of JTA's claims, it isn't going to cause any private developers to run to the busway and unload a 200 million dollar building project, because it's a magic bus. The flexibility of the bus routes, and the fact that if BRT falters it can be quickly changed, is the very reason mass development won't happen along it's routes. Lastly, you won't see a single bus operator, pulling 9 more coaches down the street. For that reason alone, bus costs more to operate.

So is your host anti bus or BRT? Not in the least! BRT has a huge role to play in our transit future, both at home and across the nation, just don't try and sell it as a "Trunk Line" or "Mainline Transit." Jacksonville would soar to national and international prominence simply by going with rail, where we already have tracks. Next our City should be building a urban, ground based people mover system such as modern streetcars or even traditional streetcars. Complete the Skyway into the near urban neighborhoods and link it to a system of park and ride, easy exit, easy entrance, transit centers built around the City core. The transit centers would serve to transfer passengers from Auto, Commuter Rail, BRT, Bus, to downtown streetcars, Skyway and Trolley buses.

Quite simply put, everything has it's place and mix sells in transit just like it does at your favorite department store. Skyway, Streetcar and real electric trolley shuttle buses downtown would keep our urban heart clean and very mobile. Building a core on systems that are permanent would open a World of new smog-free development. In the suburbs, Commuter Rail could race for St. Augustine, Green Cove Springs, Orange Park, Flemming Island, NAS JAX, Nocatee, JIA, Baldwin, Marietta, Yulee and Fernandina Beach. From the transit centers BRT and regular City Buses could reach into the Beaches, JTB, Normandy, Blanding, Middleburg, Mandarin, Lem Turner, Edgewood, Moncrief, and Martin Luther King, using less costly HOV and restricted lanes, with some signal priority.

Jacksonville could go from distant follower, to true leader, if we just stand up and lead! Mister Mayor? I'll volunteer!

Poor Little Sheep In Jacksonville

"We are poor little sheep,

That have lost our way,

Bah, Bah, Bah..."

Mass Transit in Jacksonville, has become the "BLACK SHEEP," of a can-do City. Frankly, we CAN'T DO MASS TRANSIT! Why? The reasons are myriad, but not the least among them is a lack of will, a professional highway building agency playing Mass Transit expert, and a host of missteps and wrong turns at every junction in the path. Jacksonville needs to effect changes at JTA and restore its mission to that, in which JTA excels, building our highways. If JTA is to remain as our sole highway transportation provider, then consideration should be given to a new RTA or "Rapid Transit Authority," that could take over the hoped for: rail commuter district, downtown shuttles, Skyway and planned streetcars. My hope is that this blog will examine the past and present failures of Jacksonville, and help chart the course for remaking our City.

We have all heard the excuses, "Jacksonville is too small", "Jacksonville is too big", "Jacksonville doesn't have density", "Much of Jacksonville is too dense for rail." In a City of a million and a half persons, the reasons for JTA and FDOT's past failures are fading fast. Project after project has been canceled, half built, or abandoned to an unknown fate. The Hart Bridge-JTB freeway, The 20Th Street Bridge over the St. Johns River, The University Blvd Bridge over the St. Johns River, The incomplete and nearly abandoned Skyway, A stillborn light rail "study" and another commuter rail "study", all lost projects of JTA. Yet our press and our governing officials continue to run to respect JTA and FDOT for their expert advice on everything from parking meters, (which have killed downtown retail and restaurant business) to fare increases for lightly patronized buses (which will now be less utilized).

The Jacksonville Skyway Express was billed as "THE FUTURE" of rapid transit in America. We would have built a regional rail system of 15-20 miles for the Skyway investment, but we trusted UMTA and the Godbold administration to Shepard our money. The light-rail plan was labeled as a mere tourist toy, this is Jacksonville, THE CITY, we don't deal with carnival people or tourists. The City, JTA and FDOT, knew where we could get a REAL futuristic transit, so we played follow the leader. We were told a 4.3 mile "system" would do away with buses on surface streets. Sleek 4 car or 6 car trains would quietly and electrically whisk commuters above the downtown congestion. Millions of dollars of new development would follow our "Buck Rogers" planning and locate along the Skyway. 8,000 to 16,000 persons a day would flood the system to reach surrounding urban park and ride garages, each in turn becoming a mini-transit center. Lines would reach the Stadium District/Fairfield, 8Th Street Hospitals in Springfield, San Marco or even San Jose, and deep into Riverside. Union Station would become a hub of activity with a huge convention center/transit complex that would rival the great cities of the frozen North. The future was without limits, the Skyway could even someday reach the Airport and the Beaches claimed it's zealots.

Today, almost 30 years later, we still have 2 car trains. There has been no real development along it's route and perhaps ZERO that could be directly linked to it's presence. The crowds never came, today the Skyway operates empty, costing the taxpayers about $17.50 for every passenger that boards it. The convention center was under-built, the Skyway incomplete, and the transit center, just now on the drawing boards. If everything goes according to plan, the new transit center will sprawl over 8 blocks of downtown, just in time for us to move the Convention Center. Springfield? San Marco? Riverside? Stadium? Fairfield? never completed, ugly dead end Skyway tracks hang in the air where such progress was promised.

Not to fear JACKSONVILLE! Always one for a cheap bargin, we have found a new solution, we are going to build a new "SKYWAY" for City Buses. Over the top of railroad tracks that are already in place. With heavy promotion from Washington DC (the same fellows that GAVE us the Skyway in the first place) JTA now proposes to build elevated 2 and 3 lane freeways for buses. The cost? ONLY $26 MILLION dollars a mile! Trust the DC experts to fix Jacksonville, they will spread that sum over 25 years to build it out. So allowing for inflation on our 25 odd mile "super bus system" will cost a cool BILLION DOLLARS! When they are done, at the very least, we will have some more roads and a few more buses. At the best, they say it will cause a ridership explosion and when it does, we can then rebuild the whole system to RAIL.

This line of DC Talk, is rather like tearing the bathroom out of your house and rebuilding the old privy... (ripping out railroad lines and replacing them with busways)...then if there is a demand, we'll go back in and build a bathroom! (a new rail line). BRT is easy to convert to rail we are often told, well I hope so, because more and more cities that have it around the world are taking it down for rail.

In a very democratic process, they have held the required "town meetings" where citizen input was invited and carefully controlled. The local media didn't even bother to attend, most of the City never knew what was said or done. No one cared. Those few who did attend were snowed by a dog and pony show. Their positive comments droned on and on, and to the few who came to protest? "Your 3 minutes is up, please sit down!" Where points were scored against the BRT or "BUS RAPID TRANSIT PLAN," the record isn't clear. JTA seems to have lost the court reporters transcripts, and the tape recordings. Honest, we have asked for them. I'd love to print them here, both pro and con, but poof they're gone.

BAH! BAH! BAH!